Signs Your Domain Reputation Is Dropping (& What to Do)
Your domain reputation plays a decisive role in ensuring whether the emails are delivered to your receiver’s inbox, spam box, or blocked by the sending server. In the case of businesses engaged in lead generation through B2B communications, bad email deliverability might cause difficulties apart from poor campaign results. Your prospects who fill out the contact forms, ask for demo presentations, download resources, and ask for help will not receive their confirmation messages and follow-ups.
The decrease in the quality of the reputation of your domain might cause such effects as high bounce rate, complaints regarding spam, low reply rates, and rejected messages. Nevertheless, bad email performance does not necessarily indicate poor domain reputation because authentication issues, old contact lists, inappropriate messaging, and sending behavior can have the same effects as well.
What Is Domain Reputation in Email?
Domain reputation is the extent of the trust that mailbox providers place on the domain from which emails have been sent. Providers take into consideration various factors such as complaints, bounces, sending behavior, recipient interaction, and authentication results.
Having bad domain reputation raises the probability of your messages going into spam or getting rejected from the receiver server. However, having good domain reputation does not ensure that your message will get delivered to inbox.
Domain reputation and IP reputation are related but different. Domain reputation reflects the trust associated with your sending domain, while IP reputation reflects the trust associated with the server's sending IP address. Both can influence email filtering decisions.
Why Email Deliverability Matters for B2B Lead Generation
Email deliverability is one of the critical components of the lead generation process within B2B marketing. Indeed, while collecting the prospects' contact details is the first step to the customer journey, further actions that are needed after this to keep in touch require the use of email marketing tools.
As an illustration, let us assume there is a potential client who fills out the contact form asking for more information about a particular SaaS product. The company will likely send the auto-responder message and other messages containing product details, meeting schedule, frequently asked questions, etc. However, if the email fails to reach the recipient's inbox due to some deliverability issue, the potential customer may not get the required information, and the sales team will have a chance lost.
Businesses should therefore consider email deliverability when designing their lead capture and follow-up processes. This includes:
- Form submissions confirmations: Make sure your leads receive the confirmation messages once they complete their form submission.
- Lead nurturing emails: See to it that the emails sent to your leads are being delivered especially those which have valuable content in them.
- Demo and consultation requests: See to it that all relevant scheduling and sales communication are delivered to their rightful recipients.
- Data quality: Collect your email addresses in the most accurate way possible using your website before adding those contacts to your marketing list.
- Preferences: Ensure that you let your leads know about your expectations as well as how they can unsubscribe from your marketing list.
Having a good connection between lead capturing and emails is essential for companies to maintain contact with their leads after the first interaction. Domain reputation is one of the aspects of this relationship along with appropriate content and proper sending practices.
What Are the Signs Your Domain Reputation Is Dropping?
Look for changes across several metrics instead of relying on one number. Compare current results with your normal performance to identify unusual patterns.
1. More Emails Are Landing in Spam
When your domain reputation is weak, your previously inbox-reached emails start to land in spam. The receiving server is accepting the messages that's why your sending platform still report successful.
Authentication failures, irrelevant content, or recipient complaints can also result in spam placement.
In B2B organizations, however, it could go beyond typical marketing activities. Automatic emails that would be sent when prospects filled out the contact form or downloaded an offer could be rejected. This means that prospects interested in your offer would not receive the confirmations or follow-ups.
What to do: Test inbox placement across the providers your audience uses. Compare results and review recent changes to sending volume, message content, contact lists, and authentication.
2. Your Bounce Rate Is Increasing
A bounce refers to the failure of an email to be delivered to its destination. Hard bounces indicate a permanent issue with the email recipient’s mailbox, while soft bounces refer to a temporary problem such as full mailboxes, server issues, or receiving limitations.
It is imperative for companies that create leads by filling out forms on their websites to focus on the correctness of the entered email addresses. Inaccurate addresses, typos, and obsolete contact details increase the chances of emails bouncing once they are entered into the email marketing program.
An increasing bounce rate may indicate either a bad list or any technical issues. Consistent bouncing emails to invalid recipients may cause you to develop a bad reputation.
What to do: Eliminate hard-bounced recipients, address persistent soft bounces, and validate recipients before mailing.
Stay away from unvalidated lists that include invalid recipients and unintended recipients.
3. There Are More Spam Complaints
A spam complaint is the process of marking a message as spam. This can be caused by sending irrelevant mail, sending it too often, or sending it to people who do not know the sender.
In addition, spam complaints may also be high if companies keep sending follow-up emails to prospects without taking into account their initial query or how they prefer to communicate. It is crucial that B2B marketers tailor their email campaigns to match the information prospects initially requested.
According to Google, it is best to keep the spam complaint ratio in Postmaster Tools under 0.1%. You should not reach 0.3% or more; it does not apply to all email providers but only Gmail.
What to do: Analyze the campaigns that generate the most spam complaints. Target better, avoid following up too often, and unsubscribe people easily.
4. Emails from Receiving Servers Are Getting Deferred or Rejected
Deferrals, rate limiting, and rejection are signs that the receiving servers are blocking your email. Some error codes will mention reputation issues, while others may refer to authentication or policies.
Action required: Examine your bounce emails and the SMTP codes. Find out which provider(s) are experiencing the problem and what it could be – reputation, authentication, too much mail, server setup, etc.
5. Replies and Engagement Are Dwindling
A decrease in replies, clicks, or some form of engagement could mean that fewer people are receiving your emails or that the message you are sending is no longer relevant.
Lower engagement cannot conclusively show that the reputation of your domain is deteriorating. Low-targeting, unappealing offer, and alterations in customer behavior can have a similar effect. Open rates cannot always be relied upon since they may not necessarily correspond with a customer opening their mail.
When it comes to B2B lead nurturing, low engagement levels can also signify that the follow-up emails sent to the prospect have become irrelevant to him. It is therefore essential to examine whether the emails being sent are relevant to the initial form filled out by the prospect.
What to do: Analyze campaign performance per provider, audience, and sending domain. Check the placement of emails along with other metrics such as replies, bounces, and complaints.
6. Your Domain/ IP Is Listed On A Blacklist
A blacklist is a set of IP or domain names which are involved in spam mailings. There are receiving systems that make use of such blacklists while determining whether to accept emails or not.
The significance of each listing will vary. It is determined by the type of the blacklist and the receiving provider.
Action Plan: Verify your domain/IP address from the blacklists. Understand the reason why you were listed and solve the problem.
7. SPF, DKIM, or DMARC Tests are Failing
Authentication of emails is important for validating the legitimacy of emails sent. Failing authentication tests can lower the trust level of valid emails and result in problems related to the sending of such emails.
These authentication methods are especially significant for companies using automated messaging via different platforms. For instance, a business may utilize one platform to deliver emails from website forms, another to distribute its marketing messages, and yet another to send sales messages. All the legitimate sending services must be included in the authentication of the domain.
This problem may arise following changes to the DNS settings, a change in the email provider, or an additional email sending service being added.
What you should do: Check your SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records and make sure all valid email sending services have been authorized.
What Causes Domain Reputation to Drop?
There are several sending and technical problems that might harm the reputation of the sending domain:
- Poor-quality contact list: Email addresses that are invalid, outdated, or collected incorrectly might result in increased bouncing.
- Unwanted emails: Emails sent to people who have not subscribed for emails will likely trigger increased spam complaints.
- Unexpected spikes in sending: A sudden increase in the activity of sending emails will attract more attention to the mailing from mailbox providers.
- Errors in authentication configuration: Mismatches in SPF, DKIM, or DMARC records might result in receiving servers being unable to verify emails.
- Unauthorized sending activity: Hacking into a company mailbox and sending emails through it might hurt the reputation of the company domain.
- Irrelevant emails: The content of the email does not correspond to the recipients' interests.
- Inaccurate lead data collection: Badly gathered data on customers might lead to complications while mailing them by emails.
There may be more than one factor that causes a decrease in the reputation of the domain. For instance, an inaccurate B2B email campaign sent to an outdated contact list will both increase the rate of bounces and generate spam complaints.
How do you check the Reputation of Your Domain?
Assessing the domain reputation includes examining domain reputation reports, email authentication outcomes, inbox placements, and email campaign deliverability. These factors will help businesses determine whether their issues with email deliverability stem from sender reputation, configuration, or recipient engagement.
Check Reputation and Delivery Statistics
There might be reporting tools from mailbox providers for reputation data, spam reports, authentication data, and delivery errors. The availability of these tools will depend on the service provider.
Test Inbox Placement
The inbox placement test helps identify if the test emails go to the inbox or into the spam folder for all the supported providers. It helps identify variances in the receiving systems, but not every email can be assured of its place in advance.
Testing for delivery problems of various emails such as marketing campaigns, form submissions confirmations, and automated follow-ups will be important. Testing this aspect of email marketing will help determine if delivery problems affect business emails generally or only specific email campaigns.
Review Authentication and Blocklists
Check your SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records for any errors. Look up blocklists if you face any issues with rejection or blocking.
Comparing Campaign Metrics
Look for any trends regarding your bounce rates, complaints, responses, click-throughs, and delivery failures. This may help pinpoint when the trouble started.
Email deliverability tools will assist you in reviewing these metrics, solving technical problems, and observing changes in the performance of emails. No one factor can provide all information; thus, you should analyze several sources of information before taking further actions.
How to Protect Lead Quality When Collecting Email Addresses Through Forms
The contact form on websites is usually a good beginning for the subsequent email communications in B2B sales. If the visitor asks for a product demo, downloads a whitepaper, or sends a general inquiry, the email address provided through the form could be involved in the process of lead nurturing by the company.
Nevertheless, bad contact data and undefined terms of communication may cause issues for the company in the future. Here is what businesses should consider when creating their lead capture forms:
- Utilize email validation: Perform necessary email field validation in order to detect incorrectly entered email addresses.
- Request necessary information: Gather the information which will help to provide a response to the inquiry without over-complicating the form.
- Define the terms of communication: Let visitors know what will happen once they complete the form and whether they would receive any marketing emails from you.
- Get proper consent: Provide proper consent if necessary in order to allow the user to join your email lists.
- Send related confirmation emails: Send the confirmation emails related to the request (demo, consultation request, etc.)
- Validate contact data: Validate the contact data before entering them into your marketing campaign.
Properly designed lead capture strategy may prove helpful in collecting more valuable contact details and establishing more effective transition from website to email interaction. Nonetheless, no matter how perfect the validation of the form is, there are still no guarantees that the entered address actually belongs to its owner or that future messages will reach the target recipient's inbox.
How Can You Recover a Damaged Domain Reputation?
The process of restoration of domain reputation depends on the reason and the seriousness of the problem. Here is how you can solve the problem without exposing yourself to further dangers.
1. Find out What is Causing This Issue
Find out which lists, accounts, and receiving servers are affected. Check recent email campaigns, bounce notifications, authentication status, and anything else out of the ordinary.
Also identify which business communications are affected. Check whether the problem is limited to marketing campaigns or also affects website form notifications, demo confirmations, and automated follow-up emails.
2. Stop Problematic Campaigns
If a particular campaign has a high level of complaints, invalid contacts, or mysterious rejections, pause the campaign. In case of compromised accounts, secure your account first.
If the problem originates from a poorly targeted lead generation campaign, review the contact source, audience criteria, and follow-up frequency before restarting it.
3. Fix List and Authentication Problems
Clean up any bad contacts and fix any issues with your DNS or authentication. In case contacts report email as spam, consider why and how you gathered these contacts.
Review the contact collection process as well. If inaccurate addresses are entering your database through website forms, improve field validation and introduce appropriate verification measures.
4. Resume Sending Gradually
When the problem is addressed, you can begin to send email again on a scale that would be appropriate for you. Keep an eye on bounce rates, complaints, delivery issues, and how well you're hitting people's inboxes as you increase your volume.
There is no standard timeline for this process. Some technical issues are easy to fix, while some reputation issues can take a day or two.
5. Monitor Your Performance
Keep watching your complaints, bounces, deliverability and inbox placement performance. Check new performance data against your baseline to spot recurring problems.
The deliverability of emails is another crucial aspect of B2B lead generation since obtaining the contact information of a potential customer is just one piece of the puzzle. After filling out a form on a business' website, companies will use auto-responder and follow-up emails, among other strategies, to reach out to leads. If those emails are blocked or end up in spam, a business can easily lose valuable prospects and struggle with communicating effectively with potential customers.
In order to make sure that a lead is converted into a real sales conversation, a company needs to integrate its lead generation and emailing efforts. It means that it will have to collect contact information from website forms, inform users about follow-ups and monitor deliverability.
In the case of B2B teams, the process needs to involve automation through emails sent in response to web forms or demos. This will help to make sure that customers receive the messages that they expect to receive.
How Do You Protect Your Domain’s Reputation from Issues in the Future?
Consistent and responsible use of email is critical to preserving your domain’s reputation and enabling reliable B2B communications.
- Verify the recipient email addresses prior to including them in your marketing campaigns.
- Leverage web form validation to minimize incorrectly formatted contact details.
- Do not send any emails to unsubscribed and permanently bounced recipients.
- Set up SPF, DKIM, and DMARC properly for all legitimate sender services.
- Avoid sudden spikes in email volumes.
- Segment your contacts based on their interests, inquiries, and communication preferences.
- Make sure that follow-ups related to form submissions or customers are relevant.
- Include an unsubscribe feature in all of your marketing emails.
- Protect your business mailbox and track abnormal sending behavior.
- Track your bounce rates, spam complaints, and deliverability.
Keep tabs on email delivery performance in case of any significant changes to your marketing, web form, or email infrastructure.
Choosing Email Deliverability Tools for B2B Marketing Teams
There are tools specifically aimed at checking email deliverability that can assist B2B marketers in monitoring sender reputation, testing inbox placement, performing authentication check, and identifying potential deliverability issues. They are very helpful in the case when companies have several sending accounts or run lead nurturing campaigns.
While selecting an email deliverability tool, pay attention to the following features:
- Sender reputation monitoring: Helps to detect any possible changes in domain and IP reputation.
- Inbox placement testing: Shows how the test messages are delivered across the supported email providers.
- Email authentication tests: Helps to detect configuration errors with SPF, DKIM, and DMARC.
- Campaign monitoring: Helps to gain insights into delivery performance and possible sending issues.
- Multiple mailbox accounts: Useful for agencies and B2B companies using several email accounts for sending emails.
- Reporting and integrations: Makes it easier to analyze delivery performance along with other marketing processes.
EmailPond, for example, has email warm-up, sender reputation monitoring, inbox placement testing, and API access. At the same time, deliverability monitoring tools do not guarantee inbox placement and repair domain reputation by themselves. Companies have to use proper contact list, proper sending, secured account, and relevant email content.
FAQs
1. Is it possible for the domain reputation to fall drastically all of a sudden?
Yes. It is possible because there may be an abrupt rise in complaints about spamming, hacked emails, high volume of emails being sent to incorrect addresses, and email authentication issues. Check the recent sending behavior, mailbox security and the error logs provided by the providers.
2. What methods could help me know that my emails are being delivered into the spam folder?
Perform an inbox placement test and see the available reputation reports provided by the mailbox providers. Check the delivery performance against Gmail and Outlook.
3. Is it harmful to send emails to purchased lists?
Yes. Email lists that you buy may include old and irrelevant email addresses. Your emails will result in higher bounce rate and spam complaints. B2B companies must concentrate on contacting those contacts who actually need to receive their emails.
4. How long does it take to fix domain reputation?
The time taken will depend on the reason for the problem and how serious it is. Fixing the problem of the authentication process will help solve the problem much faster compared to when the problem is due to continuous spam complaints or improper sending practices.
5. Does email warming help fix domain reputation problem?
Email warming alone is not enough for fixing a bad domain reputation problem. Although it helps build a sending history for a new or unused mailbox, there is still the need to address issues of authentication problems, bad contact list, security issues and improper sending practices.
6. What is the difference between domain reputation and IP reputation?
Domain reputation is the reputation that the mailbox providers have about your sending domain, whereas IP reputation is the reputation of the sending IP of the server.
7. What is the recommended frequency of checking domain reputation?
Domain reputation needs to be checked regularly, especially before and after the launch of major campaigns, changes in your email infrastructure, and increased email sending volume. Companies that have frequent B2B email campaigns need to monitor their delivery statistics.
8. Is it possible to solve the problem of domain reputation through sending domain change?
Switching your sending domain will not help you solve the problem of bad practices. The same problems may appear if you continue your activity under a different sending domain, so find the reason for the problem before you make such changes to your sending infrastructure.
9. How does the deliverability of emails affect B2B lead generation?
The deliverability of emails affects how businesses can get in touch with prospects after obtaining their contact information. Bad deliverability can lead to failure of prospects getting their confirmation emails, demos, and other messages. It is necessary to keep the data about leads accurate and email practices relevant.
About the Author
